As an Amazon Associate, I Earn from Qualifying Purchases. Read Disclaimer
Choosing the right pocket knife can be a tough decision, especially when you’re looking at iconic brands like Buck Knives. Two of their most popular models, the Buck 110 and the Buck 112, often top the list for those seeking a reliable and timeless folding knife. But which one is the better choice for you?
This comparison dives deep into the details of the Buck 110 Folding Hunter and the Buck 112 Ranger, exploring their features, build quality, and overall performance. We’ll examine their differences to help you determine which knife best suits your needs, whether you’re a seasoned outdoorsman or simply looking for a dependable everyday carry.
Get ready to explore the legacy of these legendary knives, comparing their blade shapes, handle materials, and overall feel. By the end of this article, you’ll have a clear understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of both the Buck 110 and the Buck 112, empowering you to make an informed decision.
Specs at a Glance:
| Feature | 110 | 112 |
|---|---|---|
| Blade Material | 420HC Steel | 420HC Steel |
| Handle Material | Macassar Ebony Dymondwood | Macassar Ebony Dymondwood |
| Blade Length | 3.75 inches | 3 inches |
| Closed Length | 4.875 inches | 4.25 inches |
| Weight | 7.2 oz | 5.6 oz |
| Locking Mechanism | Lockback | Lockback |
| Blade Shape | Clip Point | Clip Point |
| Carry System | Leather Sheath | Leather Sheath |
| Handle Construction | Brass Bolsters, Riveted | Brass Bolsters, Riveted |
| Blade Grind | Hollow Grind | Hollow Grind |
| Country of Origin | USA | USA |
| Opening Mechanism | Manual | Manual |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Blade Length
- Buck 110: The Buck 110 boasts a 3.75-inch clip point blade, providing ample cutting surface for various tasks. This longer blade excels at slicing and piercing but can be less compact for pocket carry.
- 112: The Buck 112 features a slightly shorter 3-inch clip point blade, making it more compact and easier to carry. This shorter blade is still capable but might require more strokes for larger cuts.
- Winner: 110
Overall Length (Open)
- Buck 110: Open, the Buck 110 measures 8.5 inches. Its extended length offers a comfortable grip and leverage during use. It can feel bulky in the pocket.
- 112: The Buck 112 is shorter at 7.25 inches when open, making it more manageable. Its reduced length enhances portability.
- Winner: 112
Weight
- Buck 110: The Buck 110 typically weighs around 7.2 ounces. This weight, while substantial, contributes to its sturdy feel and durability.
- 112: The Buck 112 is lighter, weighing in at approximately 5.6 ounces. This lighter weight makes it more comfortable for extended carry.
- Winner: 112
Handle Material
- Buck 110: The classic Buck 110 features a handle made of wood (typically Macassar Ebony or Dymondwood) with brass bolsters and liners, offering a premium look and feel. Wood handles require more maintenance.
- 112: The Buck 112 often uses wood handles, but also has versions with other materials like phenolic resin, which are more resistant to the elements.
- Winner: Tie
Locking Mechanism
- Buck 110: Both the 110 and 112 utilize a reliable lockback mechanism, known for its secure blade lockup.
- 112: Both the 110 and 112 utilize a reliable lockback mechanism, known for its secure blade lockup.
- Winner: Tie
Blade Steel
- Buck 110: The Buck 110 typically uses 420HC steel, known for its good balance of edge retention, corrosion resistance, and ease of sharpening.
- 112: The Buck 112 typically uses 420HC steel, known for its good balance of edge retention, corrosion resistance, and ease of sharpening.
- Winner: Tie
Carry Method
- Buck 110: The Buck 110 includes a leather sheath for belt carry. The sheath is durable and protects the blade, but can be less convenient than pocket carry.
- 112: The Buck 112 also comes with a leather sheath for belt carry. This is similar to the 110 but may be more compact.
- Winner: Tie
Price
- Buck 110: The Buck 110 is often slightly more expensive than the 112 due to its larger size and sometimes premium handle materials.
- 112: The Buck 112 is typically more affordable, making it an excellent value for its quality.
- Winner: 112
Winner by Category:
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Overall Value | Tie |
| Blade Size | Buck 110 |
| Portability | Buck 112 |
| Handle Comfort | Tie |
| Durability | Tie |
What They Have in Common:
- Blade Material: Both knives utilize 420HC steel for the blade, providing a good balance of edge retention, corrosion resistance, and ease of sharpening.
- Handle Material: Both models feature handles made from Macassar Ebony Dymondwood, offering a classic look and comfortable grip.
- Locking Mechanism: Both knives employ a reliable lockback mechanism, ensuring the blade stays securely open during use.
- Carry Method: Both knives come with a leather sheath for convenient and safe carrying.
- Country of Origin: Both the Buck 110 and 112 are proudly made in the USA.
Buck 110 Vs 112 Buying Guide
Blade Steel and Edge Retention
The choice of blade steel is crucial for any knife. Both the Buck 110 and 112 typically utilize 420HC steel, a stainless steel known for its ease of sharpening and good corrosion resistance. However, edge retention isn’t the primary strength of 420HC. The 110 sometimes offers versions with upgraded steels like S30V, significantly improving edge retention and overall performance. When choosing, consider how frequently you’ll need to sharpen your knife and what tasks you’ll primarily use it for. The 110’s upgraded steel options provide a clear advantage for users prioritizing extended sharpness.
Handle Materials and Ergonomics
Handle materials greatly influence comfort and grip. The classic Buck 110 features a brass bolsters and wood handle, providing a traditional aesthetic and comfortable grip for many. The 112 often shares similar materials, though handle variations exist with different wood types or other materials like Micarta. Ergonomically, the 110 offers a larger handle, better suited for those with larger hands or needing more leverage. Consider how the knife feels in your hand and the type of work you plan to do, as this will influence your choice.
Size and Weight Considerations
Size and weight are important for portability and ease of carry. The Buck 110 is a larger knife, making it suitable for heavier tasks but less convenient for everyday carry. Its size is a defining characteristic. The Buck 112 is smaller and lighter, making it a better option for those who prefer a more compact knife that is easily carried. Think about your everyday carry preferences and how you intend to use the knife. The 112 offers a noticeable advantage in terms of pocket carry and general portability.
Locking Mechanism and Safety
Both knives use a lockback mechanism, a reliable and secure system that prevents accidental blade closure. This design is generally safe, but users should always ensure the lock is fully engaged before use. The lockback mechanism provides solid blade security during use. It’s a key feature contributing to the overall safety of both the Buck 110 and the 112. Regular inspection of the locking mechanism is recommended to ensure optimal performance and safety.
Intended Use and Applications
Consider the intended use when selecting between the two. The Buck 110, with its larger size and more robust construction, is well-suited for tougher tasks like field dressing game or general outdoor use. The 112, being smaller, is better for everyday tasks, such as opening boxes, cutting rope, and general utility work. If your primary needs involve more heavy-duty use, the 110 is likely the better choice. For lighter, everyday tasks, the 112 is a more practical and convenient option.
Price and Value
Price and value are important deciding factors. Both the Buck 110 and 112 are generally affordable, but prices can vary based on materials and features. The 110 with upgraded blade steel and handle materials will usually cost more. Consider your budget and the features that are most important to you. Evaluate the long-term value and expected lifespan of each knife. Both knives offer excellent value for their quality and durability, making either a sound investment.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy Buck 110 If…
- You prefer a larger blade for heavier tasks.
- You want a classic, iconic folding knife design.
- You need a knife with a longer blade for slicing and cutting.
- You prioritize a knife with a more substantial feel in hand.
Buy 112 If…
- You prefer a more compact and pocket-friendly knife.
- You want a knife that’s slightly lighter and easier to carry.
- You need a knife that’s easier to maneuver in tighter spaces.
- You prefer a knife with a smaller blade for everyday tasks.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the primary difference between the Buck 110 and 112?
The main difference lies in size and weight. The Buck 110 is larger and heavier, designed for more demanding tasks. The 112 is smaller and lighter, making it more suitable for everyday carry and lighter tasks. This difference in size significantly affects portability and intended use. The 112 is usually considered a more compact version of the 110.
Which knife is better for everyday carry?
The Buck 112 is generally better for everyday carry (EDC). Its smaller size and lighter weight make it more comfortable and convenient to carry in a pocket or on a belt. The 110, while a classic, is larger and can be less discreet. The 112’s compact design makes it less noticeable for daily use.
Are both knives good for outdoor use?
Yes, both are suitable for outdoor use. The 110, due to its larger size and more robust construction, is better suited for heavier outdoor tasks like field dressing. The 112 is still capable, but it is better suited for lighter outdoor tasks, such as food preparation or general camp chores. Both offer reliability.
What type of blade steel do these knives typically use?
Both the Buck 110 and 112 traditionally use 420HC steel. This stainless steel offers a good balance of corrosion resistance and ease of sharpening. However, some versions of the 110 may feature upgraded steels like S30V, which enhances edge retention and overall performance. Always confirm the steel before purchasing.
How do the handles differ?
The handles often use similar materials, such as wood and brass bolsters, providing a classic aesthetic. The 110 often offers a larger handle which may be more comfortable for those with larger hands. The 112 may have slightly different handle styles and materials, but the basic construction is similar. Consider handle feel when choosing.
What locking mechanism do they use?
Both the Buck 110 and 112 employ a lockback mechanism. This system is known for its reliability and secure blade locking. The lockback design ensures the blade stays open during use and prevents accidental closure. Always check that the lock is fully engaged before use for optimal safety.
Which knife is more expensive?
The price can vary based on materials and features. Typically, the 110 with upgraded blade steel or premium handle materials will be slightly more expensive. The base models are usually similarly priced. Consider your budget and the features you desire to determine the best value for your needs. Prices can fluctuate.
Final Verdict
Choosing between the Buck 110 and 112 depends on your needs. The 110 excels with its larger size and robust build, ideal for heavier tasks and outdoor adventures. The 112 offers a more compact and convenient everyday carry option. Both knives offer excellent value and reliability. Consider your intended use, size preference, and carry needs to select the best fit for your lifestyle.
Winner: Buck 112