As an Amazon Associate, I Earn from Qualifying Purchases. Read Disclaimer
Are you ready to dive into the world of 3D printing and looking for the perfect machine to kickstart your creative journey? Choosing the right 3D printer can feel overwhelming, with so many options available. Today, we’re putting two popular contenders head-to-head: the Bambu A1 and the Bambu P1S.
Both printers are from Bambu Lab, a company known for its innovative approach to 3D printing, but they cater to slightly different needs and budgets. This comparison aims to break down the key differences between the Bambu A1 and P1S, helping you determine which printer is the best fit for your specific requirements.
We’ll explore their features, performance, and overall value, covering everything from print quality and speed to ease of use and price. Whether you’re a beginner or an experienced maker, this guide will provide the insights you need to make an informed decision. Let’s get started and find out which Bambu Lab printer reigns supreme!
Specs at a Glance
| Feature | Bambu A1 | P1S |
|---|---|---|
| Build Volume | 256 x 256 x 256 mm | 256 x 256 x 256 mm |
| Max Hotend Temperature | 300°C | 300°C |
| Max Bed Temperature | 80°C | 100°C |
| Enclosure | No | Yes |
| AMS Compatibility | Yes (A1 Combo) | Yes |
| Print Head | Direct Drive | Direct Drive |
| Nozzle Diameter (Standard) | 0.4 mm | 0.4 mm |
| Connectivity | Wi-Fi, Bambu Studio | Wi-Fi, Bambu Studio |
| Motion System | CoreXY | CoreXY |
| Filament Runout Sensor | Yes | Yes |
| Camera | Yes | Yes |
| Bed Surface | Textured PEI Plate | Textured PEI Plate |
Feature-by-Feature Breakdown
Build Volume
- Bambu A1: Offers a smaller build volume, suitable for smaller to medium-sized prints. Its compact design prioritizes desk space efficiency. However, the smaller build area can limit the size of possible prints.
- P1s: Provides a larger build volume compared to the A1, accommodating bigger and more complex prints. This increased space offers more flexibility for various projects. The larger size may require more desk space.
- Winner: P1S
Enclosure
- Bambu A1: Does not feature a fully enclosed design. This makes accessing prints and performing maintenance easier. However, it may be less suitable for materials that require a controlled temperature environment.
- P1s: Includes a fully enclosed chamber, which helps maintain a consistent temperature and protects against drafts. This is beneficial for printing materials like ABS and ASA. The enclosure adds to the printer’s overall size and weight.
- Winner: P1S
Print Speed
- Bambu A1: Known for its fast printing speeds, enabling quick prototyping and efficient production. It utilizes advanced motion control systems. However, extreme speeds can sometimes impact print quality if not properly calibrated.
- P1s: Also offers impressive print speeds, comparable to the A1. The enclosed design may help maintain consistent print quality at high speeds. Print speeds depend on material and settings chosen.
- Winner: Tie
Material Compatibility
- Bambu A1: Generally compatible with a wide range of common filaments like PLA, PETG, and TPU. May struggle with some specialty materials without modifications.
- P1s: Broader material compatibility due to the enclosed chamber, allowing it to handle more demanding filaments like ABS, ASA, and nylon with greater success.
- Winner: P1S
Nozzle System
- Bambu A1: Employs a direct-drive extruder and a hotend. Offers good control over filament extrusion. May require more frequent maintenance compared to some other systems.
- P1s: Uses a direct-drive extruder and a hotend similar to the A1. The design is optimized for high-speed printing and efficient heat dissipation.
- Winner: Tie
Automatic Bed Leveling and Calibration
- Bambu A1: Features automatic bed leveling and calibration, simplifying the setup process for new users. Ensures accurate first-layer adhesion. This simplifies the printing process.
- P1s: Also includes automatic bed leveling and calibration, providing a user-friendly experience and consistent print quality.
- Winner: Tie
Filament Runout Sensor
- Bambu A1: Includes a filament runout sensor that detects when the filament spool is empty and pauses the print. Prevents failed prints due to lack of filament.
- P1s: Also features a filament runout sensor for uninterrupted printing. Provides added peace of mind.
- Winner: Tie
Price
- Bambu A1: Typically priced lower than the P1S, making it a more budget-friendly option. This can be attractive for beginners or those with limited budgets.
- P1s: Generally more expensive due to its added features, such as the enclosure and larger build volume. The price reflects the enhanced capabilities and build quality.
- Winner: A1
Winner by Category
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Ease of Use | Bambu A1 |
| Enclosure | P1S |
| Print Quality | Tie |
| Value | Bambu A1 |
| Material Compatibility | P1S |
What They Have in Common
- Corexy Motion System: Both printers utilize a CoreXY motion system, contributing to fast print speeds and precise movements. This design is a hallmark of Bambu Lab’s printers.
- Direct Drive Extruder: Both the A1 and P1S feature direct drive extruders, which allows for better control over filament and enables printing with a wider range of materials, including flexible filaments.
- Wi-Fi Connectivity: Both printers offer built-in Wi-Fi connectivity, enabling seamless integration with Bambu Lab’s ecosystem, including remote monitoring and control via the Bambu Studio software.
- Filament Runout Sensor: Both printers are equipped with filament runout sensors, which pause the printing process when the filament runs out, preventing failed prints and wasted material.
- Included Camera: Both printers include a built-in camera, allowing users to monitor their prints remotely and capture time-lapses.
Bambu A1 Vs P1S Buying Guide
Print Quality and Speed
The Bambu A1 and P1S both offer exceptional print quality, but with subtle differences. The A1 is known for its speed and ease of use, making it ideal for rapid prototyping and everyday prints. The P1S, while slightly slower, often produces marginally higher-quality prints due to its more robust frame and potentially better temperature control. Consider the level of detail required for your projects, but both deliver excellent results compared to other printers in their class. The A1’s CoreXY design contributes to its agility.
Enclosure and Safety
A key differentiator is the enclosure. The P1S comes with a fully enclosed design, offering improved temperature control, crucial for printing materials like ABS and ASA, and reducing the emission of potentially harmful fumes. The A1, being an open-frame printer, is best suited for PLA, PETG, and other filaments that don’t require high enclosure temperatures. The P1S’s enclosure also provides a safer printing environment, especially if you have children or pets.
Filament Compatibility
Both printers are compatible with a wide range of filaments. However, the P1S’s enclosed design gives it an advantage when printing materials prone to warping, such as ABS and ASA. The A1, while capable of printing various filaments, may struggle with these materials in environments that aren’t climate controlled. Consider the types of filaments you intend to use most frequently when making your decision. The P1S’s enclosed environment allows for more consistent printing results with difficult materials.
Features and Technology
Both printers boast advanced features. The A1 benefits from its advanced flow sensor, automatic bed leveling, and first layer calibration. These features make it exceptionally user-friendly, particularly for beginners. The P1S offers similar features with the added advantage of the enclosure and the ability to integrate with the AMS (Automatic Material System) for multi-material printing. Consider which features align best with your printing needs and experience level.
Ease of Use and Setup
The A1 is renowned for its plug-and-play setup and user-friendly interface. Its automatic calibration features simplify the printing process, making it an excellent choice for newcomers. The P1S, while requiring a slightly more involved setup, is still relatively easy to get started with. Both printers benefit from Bambu Lab’s intuitive slicer software, making the printing experience smooth and enjoyable. The A1 is generally considered the more accessible printer for beginners.
Price and Value
The A1 is positioned at a lower price point, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious users or those just entering the 3D printing world. The P1S, with its enclosed design and additional features, comes at a higher price. Consider your budget and the features you need. While the A1 offers excellent value, the P1S provides a more comprehensive printing solution, especially if you plan to print with a wider range of materials. Evaluate your printing needs and budget to determine the best value for you.
Who Should Buy What?
Buy Bambu A1 If…
- You prioritize ease of use and a more streamlined setup process.
- You’re looking for a more affordable entry point into the Bambu Lab ecosystem.
- You value the convenience of the A1’s smaller footprint and integrated design.
- You don’t need an enclosure for printing specific materials.
Buy P1S If…
- You require an enclosed printer for printing materials that benefit from a controlled temperature environment, such as ABS or nylon.
- You plan to print with materials that produce more fumes.
- You want the option to upgrade to the AMS (Automatic Material System) for multi-color printing.
- You want a more robust and enclosed design for added print stability.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the main differences between the Bambu A1 and the P1S?
The primary differences lie in the enclosure, print speed, and intended target audience. The P1S features a fully enclosed design, ideal for printing materials that need temperature control. The A1 is open-frame and designed for ease of use and speed. The P1S is targeted toward more experienced users or those who need to print with a wider variety of materials, while the A1 is a great printer for beginners.
Which printer is better for beginners?
The Bambu A1 is generally considered better for beginners. Its plug-and-play setup, automatic calibration features, and user-friendly interface make the printing process exceptionally easy to learn. The A1 simplifies the 3D printing experience, allowing users to start printing quickly and with minimal effort. Its intuitive design means less time spent on troubleshooting and more time creating.
Can the P1S print ABS and ASA?
Yes, the P1S is well-suited for printing ABS and ASA. Its enclosed design provides the necessary temperature control to minimize warping and improve print quality with these materials. The enclosed environment maintains a consistent temperature throughout the printing process, which is essential for successfully printing these more challenging filaments. The P1S’s enclosed structure facilitates better thermal management.
Does the A1 support multi-material printing?
While the A1 itself doesn’t directly support multi-material printing out of the box, it is compatible with the AMS Lite system, allowing for limited multi-material capabilities. The P1S is compatible with the more advanced AMS system for full multi-material printing, enabling more complex designs with multiple colors and materials. Consider your multi-material needs when making your choice.
How fast can the A1 and P1S print?
The A1 is designed for speed and can print at impressive speeds. The P1S is also fast, but its enclosed design and focus on material compatibility may result in slightly slower print times compared to the A1. However, the speed difference is not substantial. Both printers offer fast print speeds compared to many other 3D printers, reducing print times significantly.
What is the build volume of the A1 and P1S?
Both printers have a similar build volume, allowing for printing of moderately sized objects. The exact build volume specifications may vary slightly depending on the specific model and any optional upgrades. Check the product specifications for exact build volume dimensions. The build volume of both printers is suitable for a wide range of projects, from small prototypes to functional parts.
Which printer offers better print quality?
Both printers provide excellent print quality. The P1S’s enclosed design and more robust frame might give it a slight edge in terms of precision and consistency, especially with challenging materials. However, the A1 also produces high-quality prints. The choice depends on the specific project requirements and the materials being used. Both printers offer excellent print quality for their price point.
Final Verdict
The Bambu A1 excels in ease of use and speed, making it an excellent choice for beginners and those prioritizing quick prints. The P1S, with its enclosure and advanced features, offers greater versatility for a wider range of materials and complex projects. The P1S is a better all-around printer.
Winner: P1S